Who wins this trade..........?

Furcal is easily the best player in this group. He is also the most fragile and to get 2 solid players in return is something I would have to consider. If Furcal stays healthy the guy with him comes out ahead, but it is pretty risky banking on him. Personally I would feel better if I were the guy getting Aviles & Sandoval, each also is multi-position eligible (important to have a couple guys that you can move around if an injury or slump is killing you).